The VG Resource

He should probably be standing up completely straight instead of hunched over.

its not bad but i think theres just too much detail i think you should lessin up on the add ons but its not too bad
heres the pic i used
http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs35/f/2008/2...uxmage.png

Next time you make something you should use a better reference :/

it looked pretty good considering it came from this http://photic.slimemansion.com/windcryst...e/geno.jpg

I like the Shorter, Stubbier Geno.

Not necessarily pieguy's sprite. But the tall redesign is just meh.

The official Geno model is squished and made small just like Mario, Peach, and Bowser's models for that game.

i guess he could be taller and also i found out i messed up on his hat but I'm gonna give it another shot this time using the pallet lol. I'm gonna make him more classic. i do say the new is good but like shyguy grey said "it dosnt seem to much like geno".
edit; i did a bit more such as fix the stance and make him fatter also gave him red eyes

I like pieguy's lineart, but the shading is meh. Let me try something.

---

The one at the bottom

if you gave that one a body more like solinks it would be perfect imo

I think it's best keeping the tip of the hat down like the others. Unless it moves as a part of his idle.

(12-06-2009, 09:33 AM)Baegal Wrote: [ -> ]I like pieguy's lineart, but the shading is meh. Let me try something.

---

The one at the bottom

so far i like yours the best
also i made him as a doll for his intro

I think the cape is what needs work.

So far, I think Gabby's the best

(12-06-2009, 12:34 PM)HyperSonic92 Wrote: [ -> ]So far, I think Gabby's the best

gabby's is good but i think hes too skinny and he doesn't need the belt.

I don't mind having the belt. It makes his design more original. They did the same for King Dedede.