The VG Resource

Looks a lot better. I especially like the changes to the face.

Yeah, me too. The sword looks very nice now (not saying that it wasn't before, but now it's just... a bit better).

And the added shading here and there works well.

Great! But I think you should re-add that 1 pixel to his head-band if you know what I mean.

Of course I don't mind edits; this is a community project, after all.
Your edit definitely does look much better, though his jawline looks kinda weird, especially the fact that those brown pixels make a bit of a pattern. His sword looks kind of floppy, but then again, so did mine...

But the shading looks better, and there are more details.

made an edit too, mainly the head and the sword, and some minor ones here and there that you can probably ignore.

/\ /\ this is much better now. Still needs a few tweaks, but this is looking really great now!

Sploder's hair shouldn't have been changed, IMO; and the sword looks better outlined as in Ran's edit, but the other changes look fine to me~

I actually do like Sploder's hair on Ran's everything else.

I agree, especially with the new face, I can maybe try making Roy out of this, but not now!

i liked the olderish face better. it looked less generic and a bit snootier

Put the first Marths head on the last ones body and it will look perfect.

Just edited the body. It ended up a bit skinnier, but it's cleaner.

While all of these edits are undoubtedly better, and they all look great, there are just so many, I don't know which one to use! I don't even know which parts of which edits to use (though Nin's legs are certainly keepers)...

Though I do I know I don't like the face on Vic's edit, and, by extension, Nin's edit. It looks rather weird and un-Marth-ish.

There are parts of Nin's Body and parts of Vic's body that I like, but 1's head is overall superior out of the four.

I still like the first head the most.