http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...gmaker.png
http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...maker1.png
http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...gmaker.png

the hell is this? do you people accept everything or just think this is good?

http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...ssonic.png
http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...2_sora.png

these too. do we really need recolours?

http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...ballpa.png
dunno what the hell this is but that flame isnt pixel art

do we even need pixel art? who seriously needs it?

tl;dr: MOST CUSTOMS SUCK ASS

(05-03-2009, 09:42 PM)Prometheus Wrote: http://spriters-resource.com/custom_edit...2_sora.png

I don't agree with taking this out but taking everything else out I pretty much agree with.

Will do. Sorry, I went and saved pretty much everything that wasn't on tSR yet.

Although, that Powerless Sonic is pretty much how he looked in those (Fleetway?) comics, so... Fine, fine. *shrug*

The original plan was to withhold all custom sheets and only upload the good ones. I don't know where the hell that plan went.

(05-04-2009, 03:05 AM)GrooveMan.exe Wrote: The original plan was to withhold all custom sheets and only upload the good ones. I don't know where the hell that plan went.

A bunch of the ones I put up were ones that were from a while ago, ones that Dazz or Tonberry had accepted. I can gather a list if you want me to.

But yeah. I don't know what happened to that plan, so go ahead and shoot me if you'd like to.

The problem I always see with people saying "We need quality control" is that they never submit custom sprites, when they know full well that they are decent custom spriters.

We need a decent sized section - We can't just only pick the best of the best.
We pick usable sheets that are not just crap recolours - that powerless sonic sheet was good - it looked EXACTLY like the character from the comics, it doesn't make a lick of difference because it's not "totally custom" - it's useful. It's also true to its original design.

Which is fine, but there are some custom sheets that are too outdated to be useful, like some of the earlier Melee sheets and a LOT of the Pokémon sheets. I highly doubt the valitity of pokemon pixelarts, especially when some are more or less exactly the same.

http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/18688
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/18669

Well then people need to point those sorts of cases out and we'll sort it out.
But we have had people use our pixelart before, so I see that as being of use still.

Maybe not so much with Luminey's Froslass PA, though, since Devicho's looks a lot nicer.

Exactly - but fact is that it wasn't pointed out to us - we have to monitor 22,000+ sheets, so we can't always remember or see when something like that crops up...
I'll remove Luminey's now though.

Didn't I already make a topic like this once? Oh well, we'll keep it at this one.

(05-04-2009, 04:51 AM)Dazz Wrote: Well then people need to point those sorts of cases out and we'll sort it out.
But we have had people use our pixelart before, so I see that as being of use still.

And that's completely fine, but some sprites are more useful than others. You don't need that many custom Voltorb sheets, for example. Considering mone of them are in an existing style, you could remove all but two, and get the same useage.