people will overlook the game because it has too many characters? really? thats the best excuse you could think of to get rid of characters you dont like? i admit some of the clones should either go or be changed but your argument is downright silly
edit: also, this game will probably have some advantages over brawl that would make it more worthwhile to play, like (hopefully) better online and faster gameplay.

Not too many characters, not too many good choices.(All Brawlers and Gooey?).

If people already played with those characters in brawl, what makes you think they would want to play with the exact same roster on a flash game.

Well, we can tweak some characters like Ganondorf, Wolf, etc to be more unique.

(07-07-2009, 04:43 PM)Angelglory Wrote: While Pac-man's been in a Mario game before, he's never been in a fighting/action genre before. He wasn't even in Namco x Capcom aside from a small cameo, while KOS-MOS and Klonoa were both playable.

He's Had some adventure games.
And that should be just enough for the moveset.

(07-08-2009, 04:43 PM)blah475 Wrote:

(07-08-2009, 03:06 PM)blah475 Wrote: I think ROB's Down B should alternate Between Stack-it-Up and Gyromite.

Stack-it-Up (left) Gyromite (right)

But I think it's a good idea. It's just Gyromite but with blocks.

Did you just quote yourself?

(07-08-2009, 05:34 PM)clap12 Wrote: Come on people. Why build a clone machine, and then clone brawl? We would get made fun of.

Those cuts are all necessary. Toon link and young link are just versions of the original link. The rest are either clones or aren't of any favor to anyone. The limit for original characters should be 25. The rest should be additional and third party. If you go with the selection we have now, people are going to overlook this game.

Not something we would want. Don't cut most of the characters i listed, and you will have a clone on your hands

Shouldn't Gooey be a definte character.

Just dump the entire vote on list and just add PT and mew2(king).

Because if we want to make a Brawl game, we gotta take out all the characters that made Brawl great.
I think we should also take out all the great stages, too.
Infact, I've made a line up that will be so good, nobody can overlook it.

Characters:
Mario
Link

Stage:
Pokemon Stadium

Mode:
1player

That'll be the best game on the web!*


*sarcasm

Long ago I was working on my own roster. Just for some inspiration do you wanna take a look? No? Too bad...

(07-08-2009, 07:00 PM)koopaul Wrote: Long ago I was working on my own roster. Just for some inspiration do you wanna take a look? No? Too bad...

Add Lolo, Bomberman and Gooey and we're good.

(07-08-2009, 06:40 PM)sky_blue_wiggler Wrote:

(07-08-2009, 05:34 PM)clap12 Wrote: Come on people. Why build a clone machine, and then clone brawl? We would get made fun of.

Those cuts are all necessary. Toon link and young link are just versions of the original link. The rest are either clones or aren't of any favor to anyone. The limit for original characters should be 25. The rest should be additional and third party. If you go with the selection we have now, people are going to overlook this game.

Not something we would want. Don't cut most of the characters i listed, and you will have a clone on your hands

Shouldn't Gooey be a definte character.

Just dump the entire vote on list and just add PT and mew2(king).

Because if we want to make a Brawl game, we gotta take out all the characters that made Brawl great.
I think we should also take out all the great stages, too.
Infact, I've made a line up that will be so good, nobody can overlook it.

Characters:
Mario
Link

Stage:
Pokemon Stadium

Mode:
1player

That'll be the best game on the web!*


*sarcasm

Your attempt to make me look like a fool has no affect whats so ever.

The characters that made brawl great were the ones i told not to take out.
The rest were just clones/lost causes. I know that was just my opinion. But still, Including all brawl-ers will deny a more deserving character. AKA Lolo

Not Quite,
What Makes Dixie different from Diddy?
No Bowser Jr.? No Geno?
Perhaps We should wait a little before we go to conclusions.

(07-08-2009, 07:04 PM)sky_blue_wiggler Wrote:

(07-08-2009, 07:00 PM)koopaul Wrote: Long ago I was working on my own roster. Just for some inspiration do you wanna take a look? No? Too bad...

Add Lolo, Bomberman and Gooey and we're good.

Shut

UP

goddammit, shut up. We understand you want them in. Stop bringing it up every post, they are not confirmed in because you want them in.

sorry I'll shut up

But in my opinion, if we get rid of characters, they should at least be clones.

(07-08-2009, 08:11 PM)clap12 Wrote:

(07-08-2009, 06:40 PM)sky_blue_wiggler Wrote:

(07-08-2009, 05:34 PM)clap12 Wrote: Come on people. Why build a clone machine, and then clone brawl? We would get made fun of.

Those cuts are all necessary. Toon link and young link are just versions of the original link. The rest are either clones or aren't of any favor to anyone. The limit for original characters should be 25. The rest should be additional and third party. If you go with the selection we have now, people are going to overlook this game.

Not something we would want. Don't cut most of the characters i listed, and you will have a clone on your hands

Shouldn't Gooey be a definte character.

Just dump the entire vote on list and just add PT and mew2(king).

Because if we want to make a Brawl game, we gotta take out all the characters that made Brawl great.
I think we should also take out all the great stages, too.
Infact, I've made a line up that will be so good, nobody can overlook it.

Characters:
Mario
Link

Stage:
Pokemon Stadium

Mode:
1player

That'll be the best game on the web!*


*sarcasm

Your attempt to make me look like a fool has no affect whats so ever.

The characters that made brawl great were the ones i told not to take out.
The rest were just clones/lost causes. I know that was just my opinion. But still, Including all brawl-ers will deny a more deserving character. AKA Lolo

It would be cool just to add all of the existing characters, plus more, like I thought Brawl was gonna do. Just think of it as a "Brawl+" without hacks and actual content addition to the game . In addition, I think "clone characters" wouldn't be a bad idea so long as we differ them from there "Alpha Copies". Instead of people maining characters simply because of preference, we'd actually be making the clones into unique characters and people would have a better foundation on maining them, although they are or may be the same character physically or in a cosmic sorta way, which shouldn't entirely matter IMO.

However, if something like memory ever does happen to be an issue, then I'd think some cuts would be in order...

I want to make the clones different, but still familiar to Smash Bros players.

(07-08-2009, 09:33 PM)MaverickETC Wrote: However, if something like memory ever does happen to be an issue, then I'd think some cuts would be in order...

This game shouldn't be able to fill up a standard CD even with a lot of music. If we were doing 3d stuff with lots of huge textures and a bunch of CG cutscenes we might have to worry about it, but programming and sprites don't take up a lot of room. Memory really shouldn't be an issue.