Quote:Edit:

that is why

it wasn't there the last time i read

(05-06-2010, 09:17 PM)sweet georgia brown Wrote: haha


he wont get it

thast why we'll clear him any doubts.

I dont have time to put these on an image hosting site, but here are two versions of the smash balls... which is better?

(Ill change the colors later)

Honestly? All of them look really ugly.

(05-07-2010, 02:08 PM)Maneko Wrote: Honestly? All of them look really ugly.

What is wrong with them?

As I already said, they look ugly. I would also complain about the really ugly colors, but since you said that you would change them, I'll stick to the ugly shading, ugly shape, ugly etc.
Compared with the other sprites, the ball looks like a piece of paper cutout.

(05-07-2010, 02:23 PM)Maneko Wrote: As I already said, they look ugly. I would also complain about the really ugly colors, but since you said that you would change them, I'll stick to the ugly shading, ugly shape, ugly etc.
Compared with the other sprites, the ball looks like a piece of paper cutout.

Whats wrong with the shape?

Its a circle, there isnt much to work with.

And its not really shading, its just like the color growing room within, changing the color with a smoother animation, rather than just blinking.

Why do you ask for other people's opinions if you always end up making excuses to bat them away?
Honestly, first you ask for opinions, then you don't like them and start stomping on them or imposing conditions about what can be commented and what is forbidden. What the hell, man.

(05-07-2010, 03:27 PM)Maneko Wrote: Why do you ask for other people's opinions if you always end up making excuses to bat them away?
Honestly, first you ask for opinions, then you don't like them and start stomping on them or imposing conditions about what can be commented and what is forbidden. What the hell, man.

Every TSR Member.

animated it for you

(05-07-2010, 02:08 PM)Maneko Wrote: Honestly? All of them look really ugly.

Ugly or not, this post contributed absolutely no means of help.
You just said your opinion with out any real C+C. That's no good.

Thanks Rhymey, for the .gif, but i can see how the black piece makes it look bad.

Could someone by chance animate the alternate one, (with the color where the black is?)

(05-07-2010, 04:11 PM)Iceman404 Wrote:

(05-07-2010, 02:08 PM)Maneko Wrote: Honestly? All of them look really ugly.

Ugly or not, this post contributed absolutely no means of help.
You just said your opinion with out any real C+C. That's no good.

the point is

use some of your brain to discover why they're bad, and try improving from there

If someone says it's bad, it's because probably there's something wrong with it, so it's already a criticism. Sure, it's easier if you get some more details about it, but just because he only said that doesn't mean it's 'no good'.

I told him the ball was ugly looking, a post later I explained in detail why did I said the ball was ugly, but either Iceman didn't saw it or he just ignored it to have an excuse to post something here.
Also, during the ball animation some colors are hard to tell apart, especially the red before the yellow cycle.

(05-07-2010, 06:30 PM)Maneko Wrote: I told him the ball was ugly looking, a post later I explained in detail why did I said the ball was ugly, but either Iceman didn't saw it or he just ignored it to have an excuse to post something here.
Also, during the ball animation some colors are hard to tell apart, especially the red before the yellow cycle.

we all know he cant see past the inflation ball he has on