tSR's Sheet Replacement Project: WE'RE LIVE

[GrooveMan.exe]

Okay, so the thread that listed inferior sheets on PT was re-uploaded, so I've got a pretty good index of bad sheets. So all I need to do is decide what sheets should I set for the first round of sheet upgrading.

Should I take them all from the same game? Choose various levels of difficulty?

[SilvaEdge]

http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...orchic.png and http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...mudkip.png
should be taken down due to a lack of poses

[GrooveMan.exe]

Those are rips, not customs/edits.

So this isn't the thread for that, I'm afraid.

[Ryan914]

You forgot to add this to TSR;
This should also be about sheets that are missing even though they were submitted
Romancing SaGa: NPC's

[A.J. Nitro]

Just checking through the M&L Customs.

The following should be taken down:
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...b_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...o_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...r_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...a_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...s_icon.png
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...r_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...y_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...k_icon.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...1_icon.png
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...e_icon.png
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...2_icon.gif

[GrooveMan.exe]

I actually have all of those noted down already.

I'll edit this thread to set up the first replacement contest shortly.

[CeeY]

About the M&L section on TSR, I counted 45+ sheets don't belong in the M&L section. Here is some that are of no purpose at all, and should be taken off the site
And here are the sheets that can be replaced with better versions in the sectionAnd these can be moved to different sections, either because they fit the style but are not Mario series. Or they don't fit the style, and are to be moved into there own sectionsAlso Cshad and A.J pointed out some others that don't belong.

[A.J. Nitro]

Actually Falco could go under custom Star Fox, Pikachu could go under custom Pokemon, Beach Cannon and Petey could go under SMS. As well as the Marine and Sub Pop, they go under SML.

[Flare]

The ones you have pointed out as custom that can be replaced aren't bad, (not just saying that because one of mine is there), but I thought the whole point of this replacing was for bad customs so we are not losing sprites, but replacing good customs is stupid, we can have more than one Boo M&L style.

Also they all belong in that section because they are all (well for the most part) in M&L style, the section means that the sprites there are M&L styled sprites. And most of the sprites there are in the game categories as well as this section since they fall into these two categories.

And the ones in that section which people have said to be removed such as Shima's Latiku, they should just be moved to the custom section since these sprites are good just not in style.

[CeeY]

The ones you have pointed out as custom that can be replaced aren't bad, (not just saying that because one of mine is there), but I thought the whole point of this replacing was for bad customs so we are not losing sprites, but replacing good customs is stupid, we can have more than one Boo M&L style.

Also they all belong in that section because they are all (well for the most part) in M&L style, the section means that the sprites there are M&L styled sprites. And most of the sprites there are in the game categories as well as this section since they fall into these two categories.

And the ones in that section which people have said to be removed such as Shima's Latiku, they should just be moved to the custom section since these sprites are good just not in style.

They might be a little bit good, but they have like 3 poses, so they are useless.\

Actually Falco could go under custom Star Fox, Pikachu could go under custom Pokemon, Beach Cannon and Petey could go under SMS. As well as the Marine and Sub Pop, they go under SML.

Yeah, and the Falco is already in the Starfox section.

[Flare]

But its boo, he doesn't have a lot of poses normally. I don't think the reason they have three poses so they are useless is a good reason for a character that usually has been represented with 2 sprites.

[redblueyellow]

http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...mudkip.png

Doesn't have all of the poses and could be replaced by this sheet:

http://img503.imageshack.us/img503/6258/...ampud7.png

[CeeY]

But its boo, he doesn't have a lot of poses normally. I don't think the reason they have three poses so they are useless is a good reason for a character that usually has been represented with 2 sprites.

Parakoopa made an excellent Boo that has all poses and fits the style perfectly. That Boo would be replaced with Parakoopa's.

[GrooveMan.exe]

http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...mudkip.png

Doesn't have all of the poses and could be replaced by this sheet:

http://img503.imageshack.us/img503/6258/...ampud7.png

This thread concens custom sheets only.


AWWRIGHT PEOPLE TIME FOR SOME ROUND 1!
In light of the hefty number of complaints with the Mario custom section, we'll start with that.

Your 5 sheets are:
Pirahna Plant
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...ranha1.png
This sheet has suffers from some really poor shading and colouring. To be successful here; a good understanding of colour theory is vital!

Petey Piranha Pixel Art
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...tpetey.png
Oh dear... not only is the lineart very sketchy and uneven, the colouring is also out of whack. With no inherent style or size limits, if you like doing PAs, this is your real chance to shine.

Magikoopa
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...ikoopa.png
Looking kinds stiff there, buddy. This sheet could be better done by someone who has a good concept of animation and poses to make Magikoopa come alive!

Hammer Bro Mario (Superstar Saga style)
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...hammer.gif
Like water, poetry, and the milk in your refridgerator; sprites need to flow in style and consistency. If parts stand out more than others; and edits are obvious, it all looks wrong. And that's no good. An easy one for the less experienced spriters out there to show how edits are meant to be done.

Custom... Mario?
http://www.spriters-resource.com/nintend...ario-1.png
I'm not sure what to say... Let's get this one replaced, and move on shall we? >>

Just tell me what sheet you want to have a crack at, and I'll add your name to the first post. You may only attempt one sheet. If you want to switch that's fine; but your other entry is null and void. There's no limit to the number of people that can sign up, but if one sheet gets an imbalanced number of applicants, I'll block it off. You'll want to make your application quickly! Plus, if you go for a sheet with low competition; you're more likely to win~

[CeeY]

Ok I'll do Magikoopa
Also is there a deadline when this is supposed to be finished?