Which custom sheets should be taken down?

[Maneko]

Personally, I would reconsiderate the option of hosting amateur pixel art and putting it at the same level of official sprites or official pixel art.
Most, if not ALL the amateur pixel arts found here are just official images retraced and recolored anyways.

[LeleleleMAXIMUM]

The topic is about custom sheets.
You're talking about EDITED/RECOLORED sprites.

[Maneko]

JPG and PNG images are sprites now?

[Frario]

Can you guys please get rid of this 5 year old horror of mine >_>

http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/17413

[A.J. Nitro]

Done!

[Frario]

:] ! cheers!

and don't worry, that was one of the few i was ashamed of! not gonna ask for more

[Luigi-the-Chef]

Not all of those are crappy, Cshad, but some, I do agree with you. Let's just see what everyone thinks first. And Dazz, I deleted that Kirby sheet you posted. I also deleted that MLSS Koopa recolored sheet.

Edit: Can we start off by checking the Mario section since it's the biggest? I need to make sure everyone agrees on each sheet being deleted.

I need most of the Mario Section stuff...
This was on Cshad's list, but :http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/17138

[Locked Achievement]

I think that sprite sheets should only be deleted if they are custom ones AND are crappy, coz u shouldn't delete a sprite sheet if its from a game, because they usually can help people with projects and the like

[Alpha Six]

That's why the topic says "which custom sheets", bro.

[TomGuycott]

There are lots of custom sheets that I don't think are on par with what the site usually demands these days, but I'd feel like such a jerk for putting people down and saying their work is crap.

But then again, I turn into the Hulk every time I see customs that are bad edits of Zero from Megaman Zero. Not even full edits, either, just standing poses and edits of his sword slashes, and SOMETIMES one custom pose that looks completely out of place.

Now I'm mad, I need to find those sheets. -Growl-

[Ravecat]

-Supporting mine that was removed, btw-

that was really shitty

[TomGuycott]

These two have always kinda made me scratch my head. Remembered them while I was looking through customs today.

This one just doesn't seem all that great to me. Could just be my personal preference by suggesting it here, but.. =X
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/17296

And this one just kinda confuses me because it has sprite clashing, sprites from a non-sonic game, and are (apparently?) original creations and not official ones. Don't get me wrong, I love seeing crazy stuff like this sometimes, but it that kind of unofficial splicing considered acceptable for the site? A penny for your thoughts?
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/18198

[Random Talking Bush]

These two have always kinda made me scratch my head. Remembered them while I was looking through customs today.

This one just doesn't seem all that great to me. Could just be my personal preference by suggesting it here, but.. =X
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/17296

And this one just kinda confuses me because it has sprite clashing, sprites from a non-sonic game, and are (apparently?) original creations and not official ones. Don't get me wrong, I love seeing crazy stuff like this sometimes, but it that kind of unofficial splicing considered acceptable for the site? A penny for your thoughts?
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/18198

1. Yeah, I think it's about time we gave that Stealth Sneak sheet the guillotine. It's been suggested for removal a bunch of times in the past, so... *removes*

2. What is that even doing here in the first place? First of all, it's compiling someone else's sprites (Pseudo da Hedgehog's) without permission, and they're also mechs that never appeared in a Sonic game. I'm removing that one, too. *poit*

[stickperson5]

should this drybones be taken off or on its just a stonger version

[Ton]

should this drybones be taken off or on its just a stonger version

What are you talking about?