Who should've been on Brawl?

[Rakia]

Good, then maybe we would see less of you.

[DarkWalnut]

I think it would'be been cool to incorperate Skull Kid from LoZ:MM somwhere in there.
Except he seems more... Assit-Trophy-ish to me

[Battosai Rai]

Well to be realistic i feel like that would be secondary characters from the Nintendo games before they considered other people. Like Waluigi is most likely to be a character maybe even Daisy. Megaman and Issac were good ideas. People like Geno I doubt would be a character maybe an assist trophy but not a character.

[Stu70o7]

I reckon that this following list of people who should be playable for SSBB:

Shadow the Hedgehog
Ridley & Meta Ridley
Tabuu
Master & Crazy Hand
Tails
Knuckles
Mewtwo
Megaman
Rayman
Waluigi
Bowser Jr & Shadow mario
Geno
Roy
Dr. Mario
Isaac
Daisy

If you think these are bad, then too bad cos this is my personal opinion so don't be horrible

[Rakia]

I reckon that this following list of people who should be playable for SSBB:

Shadow the Hedgehog
Ridley & Meta Ridley
Tabuu
Master & Crazy Hand
Tails
Knuckles
Mewtwo
Megaman
Rayman
Waluigi
Bowser Jr & Shadow mario
Geno
Roy
Dr. Mario
Isaac
Daisy

If you think these are bad, then too bad cos this is my personal opinion so don't be horrible

Get out.
Now.

[GoldenX]

Megaman
Stafy
Gooey (maybe?)
Lyn or Isaac?
Roy
Mewtwo

Any Basic Mario enemy in my opinion would suck, and I'm pretty sure Ridley's too big. I could extend my list, but I don't feel like doing that right now.

[Ark Kuvis]

I'd prefer a Goomba than either Roy, Gooey, or Lyn =(

[Rakia]

Then you need a better preference.

[Ark Kuvis]

lol, megaman geno roy 4 smash broz lol best gam evur

[GoldenX]

Why a goomba? it would just walk into things. If you're gonna be forced to choose a basic enemy, at least pick something with a chance of having a moveset.

Not tryin to be mean here.

[Ark Kuvis]

Even a Goomba could have a moveset though.

Like, his standard B could be Headbonk, which would be like Sonic's Homing Attack. Up B would be Paragoomba. Down B could be like, Kuribo's Shoe, similar to Yoshi's Ground Pound. Side B would be some kind of biting move. Basic moves and throws would be comprised of Headbutts, kicks, and biting throws.

Like, even a Goomba could work. And it's so iconic and generic, it's the king of Canonfodder. I mean I'm not saying he's number one pick for Smash Bros. even, in fact he's probably not considered. But he COULD have a moveset just like any other basic enemy. I mean maybe one works better than the other but eh.

Fact is, I'd prefer if they worked on a moveset for Toon Ganon instead of wasting energy for any basic enemy.

[GoldenX]

Fact is, I'd prefer if they worked on a moveset for Toon Ganon instead of wasting energy for any basic enemy.

I'm gonna agree with you on this one even though we definately don't need another toon character, unless it contains something really different from the original character (like maybe a Zelda/Tetra character)

Stafy for the win

[Isaac55]

Roy is not include 10 times in this list, he is only included 5 times.

1)Roy
2)Female fire emblem character or FE character that uses a weapon besides a sword (like Rolf or Nolan)
3)Roy
4)A metroid character from the newest metroid games.
5)Mewtwo because his move sets are quite a bit different that lucario's.
6)Roy
7)Issac
8)Tetra (maybe, maybe not)
9)Roy
10)Roy
11) Ridley (If you could make him the size of bowser or charizard, then it would be fine. To play as the boss form of ridley though would be like playing as giga bowser.)

Alt. Colors
1) Dr Mario (He could have been a recolor of regular Mario, and all the moves would be almost exactly the same.)
2) Daisy (Neither daisy or peach have very good fighting skills, so daisy should stay as a recolor.
3) Waluigi (wario is in a lot of games, but waluigi isn't. Unless he was to swing tennis rackets and stomp on people like he does as an assist, he doesn't have any realistic move choices. He should stay as a recolor for luigi, and an assist trophy)
4) Boshi (The coolest Yoshi ever should be a recolor of the regular Yoshi. Just thinking about it makes me want it in brawl)
5) Sonic recolors (I'd like to see shadow, and knuckles recolors for sonic)


Things I don't want to see in brawl.
1) Megaman (two non Nintendo characters was enough for me.)
2) Sonic characters (They'd be better as recolors for now)
3) Geno (I don't think that would be a good idea)
4) Bowser Jr. (I don't like this idea either)
5) Shadow Mario (no need for more than one Mario)
6) Goomba (Self-Explanatory)
7) Any in-game boss or extremely large character (Tabuu, the two hands, ridley, Godzilla, groudon)


Most of you won't agree with any of these, but don't think you can change my opinions without some goo reasons. (I'm going to sleep now)

[Alpha Six]

agreed with 1, 3, 6, 9 and 10

[Ark Kuvis]

I'm gonna agree with you on this one even though we definately don't need another toon character, unless it contains something really different from the original character (like maybe a Zelda/Tetra character)

To be fair, Ganondorf himself is semi cloned Captain Falcon. Toon Ganon is pretty much extremely different from the current Ganondorf.

Also sdgasasgfgasgsa This is becoming the Roy fan topic god damn it even my geeky Fire Emblem reasonings and examples aren't helping much.