Which custom sheets should be taken down?

[Geo the Fox]

If a sheet has so little use, there's no point in holding it up when its space could be used for another more useful spritesheet. Cause, like, every sheet can apparently be useful, right? That's prolly true. Though using that logic... How about I submit a sprite sheet of multiple colored pixels and hope someone decides to copy paste them over and over into whatever they want? Sounds useful to me.

I'll call it the "Everything and Anything" Sprite sheet. It'll go into every custom section.


And the rips.

Especially the rips.


Sure poses shouldn't be a determining factor, but there's... a real limit. Especially on things that actually have more than a few actions. That's just inexcusable and lazy.

[Koopaul]

You know I look at certain rips like from Fairly Oddparents or something and I realize that the "crappy" customs are WAY better than these actual rips!

But seriously, maybe you should post polls on the actual site for people to vote. The user's opinions matter the most.

"Would you be likely to use this sheet?"

or

"Do you think this sheet deserves to stay on the site?"

[Dazz]

Wait wait wait, you're asking to make a poll for people vote on for over 1000 sheets?

[Koopaul]

N-no... Just the ones you can't decide whether to get rid of.

I'm just making a suggestion...

[Ton]

I made the same suggestion last page. We could take one character (Mario) and have a poll with options that correspond to each sheet.

[Ngamer01]

Instead of polling the people, the staff just uses their best judgment on deciding what goes up and what comes down. If something comes down that should have been kept and/or if something goes up that should have been rejected from the start, the people will let the staff know in their own ways (like mentioning the matter over in the Error reporting thread for example).

[CeeY]

Some of those are pretty good, Ceey, so I dunno. Anyway, I deleted some of the stuff that no one wanted, but let's talk about what BAB and Geo were discussing a few posts back.

Some of them are not useful though. You kinda have to balance the fact that if something is awesome but, it only has like two poses doesn't mean its useful.

[Bear Saxaphone]

Are you could post single sprites, because nobody wants to scroll through some huge list.

Mother Series


http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...index.html
There not bad, but not really good either. There's a much better ness on the site.

[CeeY]

Are you could post single sprites, because nobody wants to scroll through some huge list.

Mother Series
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_.../ness3.png
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_.../ness1.gif
http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...index.html
There not bad, but not really good either. There's a much better ness on the site.

This is not that bad, but it's kind of useful. I guess these kind of sheets should be reviewed, this is probably the hardest group to decide on.

[Bear Saxaphone]

I say the second one goes.

[CeeY]

I say the second one goes.

I say both.

[Solink]

I say the second one goes.

this

the first one is pretty good and have great effects. It just lack poses
but
the second one is pillowshaded and have bad pose

so keep the first =P

[Koopaul]

I don't see anything wrong with Zin's Ness. Other than the lack of poses.

I remember seeing it used like crazy in sprite comics.

[A.J. Nitro]

1st Ness can stay for now. 2nd Ness goes. BTW, even if a good sprite doesn't have a full animation, they can still be used for comics and stuff. These won't always be used in flash movies.

[Bear Saxaphone]

F Zero Series

http://www.spriters-resource.com/custom_...heet/17235
Pillowed, ugly colors, and many of people have agreed to take it off.