General Pokemon Discussion

[Phantom Killah]

That would be (looking at the Car analogy) taking 'vintage enthusiasts' in to account. It's also not often a flawless idea to take public opinion or sales as a perfect indicator of an item's quality - it's why self proclaimed gamers often discount modern game sales as being 'good' games - It can only be a theoretic suggestion, but if you were to get someone with gaming skill, but no memory of playing any games, they would naturally prefer the version of a game with more content and better mechanics. It's undeniable.

what

being newer doesn't make a game better.
more content and fancier mechanics are definite pluses, but they aren't the only factor into how good the game is.