(10-20-2009, 01:18 AM)Ekoi Wrote: The difference between Ice Climbers-and-ROB and Marina-and-Pacman is that the first two weren't wholly defined in what they could do before Melee and Brawl.
Marina and Pacman, on the other hand, are very defined, with Marina using alot of grapple moves, and Pacman being a Sonic-clone moreso than Tails is.
Personally, I would like to see as little "ideas-pulled-out-of-ass" as possible, and leave that to Nintendo when they want to take an old character like Ice Climbers or ROB and put them into Smash Bros.
Isn't this whole game full of ideas being pulled from our asses? Why does it matter? As long as its not something outrageous, why not make up something? You know if its in the flavor of that character. Ice Climbers used ice and hammer attacks (duh) ROB used robotic attacks like lasers and jets.
Ice Climbers wouldn't use lasers. ROB wouldn't use a hammer. Just make up stuff that sounds like what the character would use.
Make sense?