Tails or Knuckles?

[Ark Kuvis]

Ya, my opinion is about the same as Koopaul's. Having Tails over Knuckles makes more sense to me. Have Knuckles over Tails would be like having Wario over Luigi.

I don't think we can compare Knuckles to Wario. Unlike Knuckles, Wario has his own franchise, and can represent himself better than just being a Mario character. Probably the reason Wario appeared in Brawl as a starting character, instead of a secret character like Luigi.

If Wario Land and Wario Ware didn't exist, Wario would be a secret character in Brawl. and your comparison would work better.

But seriously, I like Knuckles better than Tails except in Sonic Adventure. So I'm biased as shit in this arguement.