11-05-2009, 02:01 PM
@Shawn, I'm going to address each of your points.
Geno: his cool factor supposedly comes from his laser and other robot-style attacks. I agree that he's overrated, but he would be the only Mario RPG series rep (other than the main 4, of course). I agree that his removal is acceptable.
Gooey: he's as much a fighter as Kirby is, really. Actually, though Omegakyogre's moveset doesn't make him a clone, he is essentially a Kirby clone with a tongue in the one game where he appears as playable. I agree that his removal is acceptable.
K. Rool: I really don't know enough about him, so I can't say anything about him right now. That means, research time!
Kos-Mos: definitely obscure. I don't really know enough about Namco's other stuff to say anything about her.
Krystal: she's another Star Fox character who ISN'T a Fox clone! That's really the only reason she should be in though; however, I think she'd have to compete with Wolf for the spot, as there's no need for 4 SF characters.
Pichu: His removal is acceptable. Actually, I think it'd be more than acceptable; aren't there, like, at least another 3 or 4 generations of pokemon since then?
Custom Robo (Ray): Agreeing. Though I don't know what you mean by unique fighting style...
Isaac: Agreeing.
Ashley: Why her? Is she actually popular enough for that?
Jill: I don't know enough about her, either...
Roy: he needs to go away. For a long time. If we get rid of him, but we still want a 3rd FE character, replace him with either Lyn, or Ark Kuvis's Heroes of Elibe idea.
Tail: I don't know much about him, but I agree that one Sonic character should be enough...
4th FE character: agreeing.
Geno: his cool factor supposedly comes from his laser and other robot-style attacks. I agree that he's overrated, but he would be the only Mario RPG series rep (other than the main 4, of course). I agree that his removal is acceptable.
Gooey: he's as much a fighter as Kirby is, really. Actually, though Omegakyogre's moveset doesn't make him a clone, he is essentially a Kirby clone with a tongue in the one game where he appears as playable. I agree that his removal is acceptable.
K. Rool: I really don't know enough about him, so I can't say anything about him right now. That means, research time!
Kos-Mos: definitely obscure. I don't really know enough about Namco's other stuff to say anything about her.
Krystal: she's another Star Fox character who ISN'T a Fox clone! That's really the only reason she should be in though; however, I think she'd have to compete with Wolf for the spot, as there's no need for 4 SF characters.
Pichu: His removal is acceptable. Actually, I think it'd be more than acceptable; aren't there, like, at least another 3 or 4 generations of pokemon since then?
Custom Robo (Ray): Agreeing. Though I don't know what you mean by unique fighting style...
Isaac: Agreeing.
Ashley: Why her? Is she actually popular enough for that?
Jill: I don't know enough about her, either...
Roy: he needs to go away. For a long time. If we get rid of him, but we still want a 3rd FE character, replace him with either Lyn, or Ark Kuvis's Heroes of Elibe idea.
Tail: I don't know much about him, but I agree that one Sonic character should be enough...
4th FE character: agreeing.