04-03-2011, 04:40 PM
Of course comparing Dedede's sprite to Kirby's make sense. Just because a sprite's bigger or has more parts to it, that doesn't make it okay to suddenly give it a different shading style. If a boss doesn't look right next to the game's -playable character-, or, y'know, every other sprite in the game (because it doesn't), then that's kind of a problem. It's overshaded and not very fitting so you can afford to try to fix it.
That said, I do like your lineart, though I didn't really have a problem with the other one either.
That said, I do like your lineart, though I didn't really have a problem with the other one either.