The Legend Of Zelda Wind Waker Rips

[Garamonde]

I see, maybe you have to render your models with alpha transparency? I can do this in Cinema 4D (I render the model to exactly 95 x 79 (the dimensions of the icon), and then I use Photoshop to put the render in manually). That should fix it. And if the model happens to stick out of the borders a bit, I re-paste just the border over-top of... the border.