TSR 2012 Nuzlocke All-Stars!

[TomGuycott]

If you get to a point where you have to progress using an HM, but have no pokemon that can use it due to the Nuzlocke rules, is that game over?

Failure Edit:

WELP, turns out that's not SO much of an issue right now since I have to start over already. Falkner kicked my ass, I forgot how much of a bitch he is without catching that Mareep south of the town. Here's all the data I compiled to make a comic out of later, but I might not now depending on whether I get better results for my next try.

Character Data:
Oswald, the really terrible trainer.

Catch Data:
Starter - Zuul Level 5 F Cyndaquil. Modest. Highly Curious. Killed at Level 11 in Violet City Gym against Falkner's Pidgeotto.
Route 29 - Ringo Star. Level 3 M Sentret. Hasty. Strong Willed. Killed at Level 7 in Violet City Gym against Falkner's Pidgeotto.
Route 30 - Archimedes. Level 4 M Pidgey. Hasty. Loves to eat. Killed at Level 7 in Ruins of Alph against a G Unown.
Route 31 - Flying Rat. Level 4 F Pidgey. Jolly. Capable of taking hits. Killed at Level 9 in Violet City Gym against a Spearow.
Dark Cave - Barbarella. Level 2 F Geodude. Calm. A little quick tempered. Killed at Level 7 in Ruins of Alph against an F Unown.
Route 32 - Ackbar. Level 3 M Ekans. Relaxed. Sturdy Body. Killed at Level 7 in Violet City Gym against Falkner's Pidgeotto.
Ruins of Alph - Holy Hell! Level 5 H Unown. Timid. Quick Tempered. Killed at Level 7 in Violet City Gym against Falkner's Pidgeotto.
Sprout Tower - Belsprout. Level 3 F Ratata. Lonely. Mischievous. Killed at Level 7 in Violet City Gym against Falkner's Pidgeotto.

Mom: Just try pressing the buttons, you'll know what to do in no time!
Oswald: What buttons!? What are you saying!!?
///

Zuul:LEER!
Kakuna:HARDEN!
Zuul:LEER!
Kakuna:HARDEN!
Infinity loop... kind of.
///

???: I'm gonna beat you!
Zuul: ZUUUUUULL!!! *Critical Hit! TKO!!*
???: WELP!
///

Police: Did you get his name!?
Oswald: -Shrug-
WANTE ???
///

Sentret Ringo Star: I am Sparticus.
Oswald: o____o
///

Pidgey used Tackle.
Ringo Star has 2 hp.
Pidgey used Tackle.
Zuul has 2 hp.
Oswald: FFFFFTTT
///

Bug Catcher: GO CATERPIE!
Archimedes eats all opponents.
///

Archimedes dies fighting a G Unown.
Oswald: Oh Archimedes.. you loved to eat...
Oswald eats Archimedes.
///

Barbarella dies fighting an F Unown.
RIP Barbarella. Headstone carved out of her head.
///

Ratata in Sprout Tower dressed as a Belsprout.
Onix trading kid does NOT fall for it.
///

Running all the way to the bottom of Sprout Tower to heal before the Rival Battle.
And then he leaves without battling.
///

Flying Rat died fighting Birdkeeper's Spearow in Falkner's Gym.
///

Everyone else died. The end.
///