Mother 3's story is overrated.

[Mutsukki]

Leder's reason to be the leader just because he's tall is one of the writings many charms. Gors has nailed it on his post above.

You know, a lie is only a lie when there's a reference point to what is the "truth". If everyone lives the life they planned out for themselves, how is that a lie anymore? Their past may be a fabrication, sure, but the life they're living right now is most definately the truth.

Fassad's betrayal was never planned. The Magypsies didn't care much about humans, so they wouldn't really mess with them, but Porky's arrival disrupted that. If anything the history is supposed to repeat itself after all and that humankind strives for happiness. They were perfectly happy with their new made up lifes, that's reason enough to justify all their actions.

I feel like I've adressed all of your other points in my earlier post too, so I end this one here.