04-06-2013, 09:12 AM
No offense, but I'm going to lock this thread. Looks like I won't because someone else was faster
Most of what can be said has been said by Sparkmouse and the rest is just a back-and-forth of PNG and JPG that doesn't look like it's going to stop.
To recap: When you post it as JPG, you don't give us anything to properly comment on, as it's impossible to tell if your pixels are good or bad because there's JPG smudge everywhere. We can't tell if your pixels are blurry or have good detail or if the shading is alright due to JPG. There just isn't anything to properly discuss here.
If you're scared about your sheet being stolen (which is kinda ridiculous because it's an edit anyways), but yet want some comments on how to improve your sprites, you should rather post only a select few in full quality instead of all of them as JPG. Posting tons of sprites at once isn't good for getting criticism anyways, as noone will know what to focus on for their comment.
Most of what can be said has been said by Sparkmouse and the rest is just a back-and-forth of PNG and JPG that doesn't look like it's going to stop.
To recap: When you post it as JPG, you don't give us anything to properly comment on, as it's impossible to tell if your pixels are good or bad because there's JPG smudge everywhere. We can't tell if your pixels are blurry or have good detail or if the shading is alright due to JPG. There just isn't anything to properly discuss here.
If you're scared about your sheet being stolen (which is kinda ridiculous because it's an edit anyways), but yet want some comments on how to improve your sprites, you should rather post only a select few in full quality instead of all of them as JPG. Posting tons of sprites at once isn't good for getting criticism anyways, as noone will know what to focus on for their comment.