Keyboard vs. gamepad

[Zero Kirby]

I simply do not care for the FPS genre anymore, and never really did minus the 007 games.

'Cause that has everything to do with this particular discussion

I'd say keyboard and mouse. Having tried both while playing TF2, I discovered fairly quickly that when using a gamepad, you are just way too slow. Sure you get increased fidelity in movement, but that won't help you if you can't aim quickly and precisely, and the mouse is the best way to do that.