I'm just not following, really. Ness is in that same boat, using the attacks of other characters from his game, because he is the mascot but himself had no applicable moves. These aspects were united. I think Sakurai even talked about doing this with Robin.
Why is DHD's abilities being based on the central aspect of the game unreasonable?
Edit: I suppose what I really want to know isn't whether or not you find it stupid, but why you think it makes him ineligible as a character given the precedent for similar situations with a large number of other Smash Bros. characters.
Why is DHD's abilities being based on the central aspect of the game unreasonable?
Edit: I suppose what I really want to know isn't whether or not you find it stupid, but why you think it makes him ineligible as a character given the precedent for similar situations with a large number of other Smash Bros. characters.