games you dislike that everyone likes and vice versa

[Goemar]

Kind of have to agree. I don't get why people love Geno so much, I think because he's stereotypically "cool" as a lot of people played the game when they were young he automatically became awesome to many. To be honest I think a lot of Mario RPG love comes from the fact that for a while, it was the only Mario RPG - and it never came out in the PAL territories, which always adds a bit of that "collectable/rare" hype (aka Radiant Silvergun).

Mario and Luigi is the far superior game in every way.