Honestly, I don't really like either. I am kinda nostalgic about melee, so I probably like it a bit more than Brawl, but I still don't think it's a very good game.
It's not polished, it looks bad, the audio quality is bad, there are lots of clones, etc.
Brawl looks better and is more polished, but it's too slow and has its fair share of stupidities. The games both have some strong points, though. Melee
is fast paced and has tight controls, and Brawl has a large cast and varied stages. I think some of the items in Brawl are pretty broken, but you can
turn them off anyway, so it's not a big deal.
Personally, I think Project M is the ultimate Smash game, but unmodded Brawl is pretty bad. If we don't count mods, then Melee is the better one.
It's not polished, it looks bad, the audio quality is bad, there are lots of clones, etc.
Brawl looks better and is more polished, but it's too slow and has its fair share of stupidities. The games both have some strong points, though. Melee
is fast paced and has tight controls, and Brawl has a large cast and varied stages. I think some of the items in Brawl are pretty broken, but you can
turn them off anyway, so it's not a big deal.
Personally, I think Project M is the ultimate Smash game, but unmodded Brawl is pretty bad. If we don't count mods, then Melee is the better one.
![[Image: sig.gif]](http://backloggery.com/fullbody/sig.gif)