12-06-2015, 04:58 AM
A 10/10 doesn't automatically mean it's perfect. It just means it did everything right.
For example, I had one school project where I had to design a robot, make a 3D model of it and animate it. My class mates had way more complex designs and way more details, while my robot was just a simple sphere with arms. I got a 10/10, because while my robot took less effort, my teacher couldn't give me a lower grade than that. I met every criteria. I did everything right, but my robot was far from perfect.
I don't have a game that ticks every box for me (maybe Super Mario Maker after a certain amount of DLC), but if there was, there's going to be a game in the future that's better. Besides, what I consider a 10 could be a different grade to someone else.
Perfect games shall never exist, because people are different and art is ever evolving.
For example, I had one school project where I had to design a robot, make a 3D model of it and animate it. My class mates had way more complex designs and way more details, while my robot was just a simple sphere with arms. I got a 10/10, because while my robot took less effort, my teacher couldn't give me a lower grade than that. I met every criteria. I did everything right, but my robot was far from perfect.
I don't have a game that ticks every box for me (maybe Super Mario Maker after a certain amount of DLC), but if there was, there's going to be a game in the future that's better. Besides, what I consider a 10 could be a different grade to someone else.
Perfect games shall never exist, because people are different and art is ever evolving.