Speed vs Strength

[Shade]

I feel most would go with the speedy dude, so just for the sake of being the contrarian...

What if McGoo was a master tactician?

Think about it for a second. Muscles might not be fast enough to dodge on the spot or keep up with Spud (these names lol) in general, but he could definitely have the capacity to predict a movement ahead of time, and no matter how slow he may be, it would be logical to assume that he could attack based on his prediction, instead of a spontaneous reaction for a potential hit. If his prediction would pay off, the fight would be over instantly. To be fair, depending on how fast Speedy actually is, this could go both ways as Speedy might be quick enough to dodge the attack, but would Spud really assume Muscles would attack in any way other than a direct attempt? If not, this would leave Speedy with a clearly exposed weakness, as not only would it set him up for defeat, but additionally his expectation would oppose the resulting situation, leaving him even more vulnerable to an unexpected and nonsensical method of attack.

All theoretical of course, so it's probably more sensible to call it a stalemate, but debating is fun! : )