05-08-2016, 08:48 PM
Oh, it's just an edit of Paper Jam Mario.
Well whatever
My previous critique still stands. The hands and feet are too large, and that's mostly due to the addition of the outline. You've made everything slightly bigger, and it doesn't translate well to certain parts. The base sprite (having no outline) has more freedom to achieve an exact shape, and when that shape is altered even slightly, it can look pretty wonky.
Break the mold a little bit. The base sprite should only be used as a starting point, not to shackle you down.
Well whatever
My previous critique still stands. The hands and feet are too large, and that's mostly due to the addition of the outline. You've made everything slightly bigger, and it doesn't translate well to certain parts. The base sprite (having no outline) has more freedom to achieve an exact shape, and when that shape is altered even slightly, it can look pretty wonky.
Break the mold a little bit. The base sprite should only be used as a starting point, not to shackle you down.