Mario In Sonic 1

[Maneko]

I already said no, Metaru. Now, if you and Iceman are going to use this as an excuse to shrug my opinion off, please say it already so we could get done with it.

[Iceman404]

I already said no, Metaru. Now, if you and Iceman are going to use this as an excuse to shrug my opinion off, please say it already so we could get done with it.

Welp. I guess I'll never understand what you mean then...

[Gors]

This is your thread and these are your sprites. You do the edits, not me.
Not wanting to fix your mistakes for you doesn't means my point is invalid, as I've noticed you have been trying to from the beginning.

You're partially right here

This thread ans sprites are Iceman's. But editing is also a way of helping him. An image says more than a thousand words.

I understand the 'you don't want to do the things yourself' part, but who said you need to do the work for him? He only asked how you thought it should be. That's all.

We edit other people's sprites often, I don't see a problem in it :/

[Maneko]

I don't have time to work on my own sprites, much less I have it to do sprites for him.
It's not that difficult to figure, honestly. :V

[Helmo]

nextime make sonic in super mario advance 2 style

[Iceman404]

to do sprites for him.

Did you even read Gorsal's post. And, you've had plenty of time to come up with an example while you were saying "No" all night.

Anyways, should do you guys think the idle is okay enough to start animating off of?

[StarSock64]

The only other change I can think of besides what's been mentioned is to change the shape of the feet altogether

because Sonic has characters with big feet and that's not something that would be hard to incorporate on Mario

[Iceman404]

The only other change I can think of besides what's been mentioned is to change the shape of the feet altogether

because Sonic has characters with big feet and that's not something that would be hard to incorporate on Mario

But remember. This isn't how Mario would look if he were a Sonic character, this is Mario in Sonic 1's style (Metaru's Post). You can't break his anatomy, and you don't have to break anatomy to fit a certain style. Mario's feet aren't as big as Sonic's. Or do you mean I should just make them a little bit larger?

EDIT: Now that I think about it, Mario has quite large feet. I'll see what I can do.

[Gors]

his leg could be a lil' longer, tho

and bigger feet

to be honest, you need to break his anatomy a little (A LITTLE) to make it fit the style, considering that Sonic style has got weird anatomy to begin.

[triptych]

I like how you said you've changed


but you're just as bad at accepting critique as you were before, stop coming up with excuses, closing your eyes, and trying to drown everything out when someone mentions a problem they have with your sprite
even if you personally don't see how it'll help, do it.

[Iceman404]

I made them both taller by 1 Pixel, but gave 1 bigger shoes. I still like the one on the left, what do you think?

[StarSock64]

why are the feet mounted directly onto the legs like they're stacked

I liked the shape of the shoes better in the last update but they all need to be brought out away from the legs

[Iceman404]