Some advice for my republic commandos?

[Name_Changer]

Shortly after SW episode 3 came out i played the DS game and loved flying around doing completely unnecessary aerial stunts while taking down my opponents. I had also played Republic Commando sometime near then and the mando spirit in me still wanted to indulge in a killing frenzy. I'm gonna stop right there before i tell my life's story on making these sprites but anyways i found them just lying around in my computer being useless so:


Here's a larger version (more bulky, not enlarged) of the episode 3 clones. Or in other words, The none decorated Republic Commando



Comparison:



Now here's Scorch, Fixer and Sev respectfully


Scorch is missing the "Dead" and "Reviving" sprites, Fixer is complete, and Sev only has walk but his look feels wrong.

So tell me what you guys think. What should I do with Sev? Judge him as is first, then look at reference pics. These were my first edits so most of the colors on him seemed half random to me at the time and i didn't dare try to making layers of red on him, fading colors were way too complex and I'm still pretty n00b.

Boss probably wont be done in all honesty. I wouldn't release a half ___ sprite sheet and since his left side and right side are different I'd have to make 2 sheets for him :s

Also here's my very first edit because i wanted to put him in a game but there were (and are) no sprites of him online. So let me introduce......



There's one sprite missing but that will be super easy once i get to it. Then I'll post here

[Locked Achievement]

I really like this! Is this purely custom or edited?

[Key]

It's edited,
Left is Original I am pretty sure.

[Dazz]

It's an incredibly minor edit...

[Name_Changer]

Yes they're edited from the one on the left. Original sprites came from the movie tie in "Star Wars: Episode III Revenge Of The Sith" on the DS and GBA.

Darth Maul however is now completely finished so here's me submitting him:


He's a pretty basic edit of Sigma from Mega Man X so if its not acceptable I understand. About the boots and belt, i decided to leave them because i don't feel like adding high black boots and a black belt would look good on an already dull colored sprite. Same with his face, i prefer the pop of the brighter colors.

---

It's an incredibly minor edit...

All of them or the Commando sheet i put up?
The commando sheet isn't supposed to be a submission but i just wanted to post it so everyone can see the poses that Sev, Fixer and Scorch have. They're not finished though so i didn't want to put up half done work

[Maneko]

I think you should ask a Mod to move this thread to the Sprite Discussion section instead.
This section is only meant for finished submissions, yours is still a work in progress. (And personally, I think they are very basic edits that anyone could have done by themselves anyways)

[Name_Changer]

okay, fair enough but can i get a second opinion on Sev? I know hes basic but i want to keep the same style as the original so they can coexist in the same game. So with that in mind do you think his red colors should be fixed up or do they fit in with the art style?