STAR V.S. RIDGE TROOPA DUEL DISCUSSION-Duel starts today!

[Shroob2]

He just seems...idk...too realistic or something? I don't know how to explain it.

To dark (figuratively) for such a happy-go-lucky place like the Mushroom Kingdom.

I think those are the words you're looking for.

[JarJar]

hit him with a haymaker star!

[Neslug]

My money's on Ridge. Well, literally.

Also, Ridge, have you finished ML2 Hooktail yet? The WIP you showed me was quite amazing.

[HyperSonic92]

Just saw you're M&L2 Bonechill. Amazing as usual.

[Ridge Troopa]

My money's on Ridge. Well, literally.

Also, Ridge, have you finished ML2 Hooktail yet? The WIP you showed me was quite amazing.

It was MLSS, and no, Bombario and I were working on that as a collab, and he hasn't been here... =/

And yes, I was going to say the same about Culex, he doesn't fit in with the ML series.

I suppose it's about time I asked, since I haven't officially decided myself... Would Macho Grubba or Cortez be a better choice? Despite the fact that I'd really like to attempt Macho I want to make sure I have the better of the two possible sprites.
If not either of those two, then which of the list I posted earlier would be best?

BTW I suggest a new topic be made when this officially starts.

[Mageker]

I'd like to see Petey, Dino Piranha, Zombone or Bugaboom =D

EDIT: I just saw the list again and I saw Hooktail... so... Hooktail!!! xD

[Star]

You sure about the new topic thing? Well wait...after thinking about it...yeah that would be best to do.

Now about your question on who would be a better choice(though this is coming from your opponent lol): I'd say Cortez. He is a very detailed character and it would be hard for me to match a character with that amount of detail. Hard to animate though..it would be mostly rotations.
Macho is also a good choice, but could be easily beaten in detail. Animation though is another thing. It wouldn
't be just rotations like Cortez. If done right, he could have amazing and flawless poses.

So, I'd say go with Macho Grubba. But, that's just me.

I've been asking for some voting on who to sprite at other places so I might as well ask here as well, who of the following should I sprite?
Bugaboom
Dino Piranha
Tubba Blubba
Smithy
Crystal King

Decided not to include Petey Pirahna or Cackletta for they've been already made in previous M&L games.

[Skink]

Smithy or Tubba Blubbla for sure

[Phantom Killah]

Tubba Blubba
you should do Tubba Blubba

[Ton]

If one of you does Macho, I don't think the other should do Tubba. It wouldn't be as exciting, I don't think. I'd love to see Smithy done, personally. But that was predicable.

[Ranbou]

I'd say to do Smithy, mostly because I'm curious to how the attacks would look.

[Tero]

Aw, I would have liked to see ML3 Petey. I'd vote for Smithy.

[Mageker]

Tubba Blubba or Dino Piranha.

[megamario1234]

Smithy should be a better choice because he can change into different forms and use a variety of attacks. For Ridge, just go with Cortez since you made an awesome job on Bonechill and maybe go with Hooktail, Bonetail, or Zombone if you change your mind.

[LeleleleMAXIMUM]

I don't know these characters, but do someone big.
Ridge's is ok, I guess, but I know Star could do better.
OOPS WHAT'S THAT? PRESSURE?
You don't say.