Player Pitch Pit (Discussion Complete)

[GaryCXJk]

Saying Hudson is a separate entity is like saying Marvel is a separate entity. Marvel still belongs to Disney, whether you like it or not.

[Alpha Six]

Bomberman is multiplatform. Hence, not exclusively Nintendo. Tell me one Nintendo game that wasn't made on a Nintendo console. You can't. You can say that about Hudson, however. Hudson is very close to Nintendo, yes. But they're not part of Nintendo. It's very, very close third party.

[Rökkan]

I think he was talking about Hudson and Konami, not Hudson and Nintendo.

But still,

Are you serious?



No, really.

Are you serious?

[Kairos]

Honestly I think we can do better.

Atlus has a pretty good relationship with Nintendo. Anything for them?

I checked, double-checked, but Atlus doesn't have any memorable character or any franchise at all. The closest thing we can put is a character from Snowboard Kids, and we won't put a Snowboard Kids character there... Will us?

Atlus' mascot is Jack Frost, which is.... A snowman... Will'o Lantern.... thing....
So yeah, no Atlus >:

Shin Megami Tensi has a shit load of games. Now most of them are on Sony Consoles ( only one on Nintendo consoles I can think of are Strang Journey and Devil Survivor) we can easily make a moveset for someone from Persona, Devil Summoner, or something.

[Rökkan]

Honestly I think we can do better.

Atlus has a pretty good relationship with Nintendo. Anything for them?

I checked, double-checked, but Atlus doesn't have any memorable character or any franchise at all. The closest thing we can put is a character from Snowboard Kids, and we won't put a Snowboard Kids character there... Will us?

Atlus' mascot is Jack Frost, which is.... A snowman... Will'o Lantern.... thing....
So yeah, no Atlus >:

Shin Megami Tensi has a shit load of games. Now most of them are on Sony Consoles ( only one on Nintendo consoles I can think of are Strang Journey and Devil Survivor) we can easily make a moveset for someone from Persona, Devil Summoner, or something.

I have completely forgotten about Persona/Shin Megami Tensei. I was going to look deeper into those games but I forgot. Still, I don't think it'd be suitable to put it in, it's rather obscure for Nintendo, and it doesn't suit SSB much.

[Kairos]

Honestly I think we can do better.

Atlus has a pretty good relationship with Nintendo. Anything for them?

I checked, double-checked, but Atlus doesn't have any memorable character or any franchise at all. The closest thing we can put is a character from Snowboard Kids, and we won't put a Snowboard Kids character there... Will us?

Atlus' mascot is Jack Frost, which is.... A snowman... Will'o Lantern.... thing....
So yeah, no Atlus >:

Shin Megami Tensi has a shit load of games. Now most of them are on Sony Consoles ( only one on Nintendo consoles I can think of are Strang Journey and Devil Survivor) we can easily make a moveset for someone from Persona, Devil Summoner, or something.

I have completely forgotten about Persona/Shin Megami Tensei. I was going to look deeper into those games but I forgot. Still, I don't think it'd be suitable to put it in, it's rather obscure for Nintendo, and it doesn't suit SSB much.

Putting in a persona rather than a character (Souji, Minato) might work. That, or I had an idea form Raidou Kuzunoha that could work.

[Ton]

I'm gonna go ahead and say "Sure, why not?" to Tingle. I'll have an updated roster asap.

[Koopaul]

Boy those last third party characters are a real pain hm?

But we all agree on Konami, Sega, Capcom, Square, and Namco. That's five huh? Hm...

I know we said against double reps but if we did that for the above we'd have 10, just two more than we were originally going to have anyway.

Konami: Snake / Simon Belmont?
SEGA: Sonic / Tails?
Capcom: Mega Man / Viewtiful Joe
Square: Geno / Black Mage
Namco: Klonoa / Pac-Man

[[robo9]]

Boy those last third party characters are a real pain hm?

But we all agree on Konami, Sega, Capcom, Square, and Namco. That's five huh? Hm...

I know we said against double reps but if we did that for the above we'd have 10, just two more than we were originally going to have anyway.

Konami: Snake / Simon Belmont?
SEGA: Sonic / Tails?
Capcom: Mega Man / Viewtiful Joe
Square: Geno / Black Mage
Namco: Klonoa / Pac-Man

I agree with Koopaul.


Except for Tails. Knuckles won that poll 29 to 35 I do believe

[tsr moderation staff]

i agree too. we're having a much harder time coming up with obscure third parties. there will be sacrifices either way but at least with two for the main third parties it's not so damn hard to get ideas. anyway, if we do that i'd say
Konami: Snake/Simon
Sega: Sonic/Billy Hatcher or Vectorman or something that isn't sonic related
Capcom: Megaman/Viewtiful Joe
Square: Geno/Black Mage
Namco: KOS-MOS/Klonoa

[Angelglory]

Ooooooor, if we can't pick a sixth, seventh or eighth company, we could just reduce the number of 3rd parties to the number we have decided on (5, 6, 7).

[Alpha Six]

let's rename this project to Super Smash Bros. Indecision

[Cshad]

@Tuna;

Why would we give Geno FF anything when he's not associated with them at all? He's a Mario character so I'm considering him first party.

[Wes]

We had a vote on how to decide how many 3rd parties there would be. 2 from each company was an option, but it lost. We should stick with 1 from 8 different companies because that won the vote.

[Gold]

I'm inclined to agree that we should go wiht the vote, but at the same time I don't think it was really thought through that hard and the two from less option seems that it would work a lot better.