Quote:If you think that girls of that age are meant to be "sexy" then honestly I hope the Party Van is already headed to your home, because dammit, guys.

wow oh boy
it doesn't matter if she's 12
girls still
look
like
girls

maneko, what the fuck is wrong with you.

when it comes to critizice others you are quite solid and we all realised that, but when it comes to take critique either you're a complete moron or just acting like a complete douchebag for the sake of look tought. at leats in the latest post. chill out sir, its not even about who's the most rude boy in town.

also

Quote:its a caricature, you need to exagerate

the whole point of exagerating is that the features that make her a girl are easily readable just like that felicia ngpc you posted. but since you 2x every single sprite you get a rather distorted vision of its native readbility. either post both normal and resized, or dont resize them at all.

Those Ash on bike sprites are pretty hot.

Good spriting hot, not flat chested Misty hot.

(06-30-2010, 01:37 AM)Lemon Wrote: Those Ash on bike sprites are pretty hot.

Good spriting hot, not flat chested Misty hot.

there are many things wrong with this post

just like manekos sprites!!!!!!

(06-29-2010, 10:13 PM)Maneko Wrote: top feeders

Its not even worth it anymore...

I sense that this thread is going down soon.

(06-29-2010, 08:47 PM)Francisco Cifuentes Wrote: all you need to do is give it more boobs bro.

lolwat

Lolis don't use tits.

(06-30-2010, 10:49 AM)*Gorsal* Wrote: I sense that this thread is going down soon.

Nah, I don't think so. The smart guys are annoying indeed, but at least ONE post was useful and I'm working on it to fix the body shape based on that it said. The boobs and curves are difficult because as I said lots of times, Misty does NOT have femenine forms and does NOT behaves in a girly way either, so the problem is making a sprite that could resemble her both in shape AND body language. (May and Dawn are a different case, and the first one is way curvier than Misty and the second one is way more femenine on her stances and motions, so they are way easier to sprite.)

Metaru, the "what the fuck is wrong with you" is actually my line. You used to give good and concise criticism by pointing directly at the flaws you could see, but somewhere during the year you got your head stuck up your ass and replied to everything with a generic "I don't like the style so it sucks" like a scratched record, AND began to bitch at the spriters instead of the sprites themselves.
How old are you anyways? Your spelling and grammar are terrible so I guess you are on your late teens as much, but your grasp of the language and ability to construct long phrases makes me guess you are like, I don't know, thirty or more.

Also, Bicycles.



This is the first board where people has complained about 2X resized sprites, so they go normal now. (Well, some LCD monitors DO tend to stretch and distort images a bit.)

The major problem here maybe isn't Misty, but more like 'do something else'. I know, those sprites are good as they are, but don't be afraid to experiment. Make different things, use different techniques, etc. That's your major flaw imo.

You have talent, but everything in this thread is Earthbound/NGP/Catgirls so it's kinda predictable and usual of yours (ironically).

Another thing, saying that only ONE comment was useful is bullshit. Most C+Cs in this site come bluntly so you'll need to actually use your brain to solve your problems, which is a better way of improving than spoonfeeding every single flaw for you (everything I said is well-covered in this thread http://www.spriters-resource.com/communi...?tid=13748 ; read it if you hasn't yet). So don't disregard them just because they don't have a single instance of sugarcoating.

---

Now, the criticism part: the sprites are better viewed in 1x because it's the native size. 2x makes finding readability issues in your sprite harder. Other than that, it's fine.

About NGP Misty, you should make her smaller than the average NGP sprites because, well, she's 12 and most characters in that size are (or look) older than her. Other criticisms still stand valid, though.

(06-30-2010, 01:19 PM)*Gorsal* Wrote: You have talent, but everything in this thread is Earthbound/NGP/Catgirls so it's kinda predictable and usual of yours (ironically).

Now that you say it, It IS ironic indeed.

(06-30-2010, 01:19 PM)*Gorsal* Wrote: Another thing, saying that only ONE comment was useful is bullshit.

Quote:there are many things wrong with this post

just like manekos sprites!!!!!!

Quote:your colours and use of black lines are atrocious

peace!!!!

I understand your point about reading the crits beyond the asshatery, but shit like this is not helpful at all, bro. Neither repeating what other people already said to look "cool". (If Iceman had added his own two cents instead of playing MeToo to Metaru's comments, it would have been a different story.)
Anyways, I will delete Misty's sprites and start again, this time from scratch.

(06-30-2010, 01:39 PM)Maneko Wrote:

Quote:there are many things wrong with this post

just like manekos sprites!!!!!!

Quote:your colours and use of black lines are atrocious

peace!!!!

I understand your point about reading the crits beyond the asshatery, but shit like this is not helpful at all, bro.

The first one was kinda uncalled for, I admit, but the second one contains a valid point. Your colors aren't attractive at all and the black outline, as Metaru said several times, limits the readability and 'eats up' space. Try using colored outlines instead of black lines and try applying hueshift in your shades.

That was the less-blunt version of Shawn's reply.

Quote:but shit like this is not helpful at all, bro.

the second one is actually incredibly true and absolutely worth looking into!!

have you ever considered this relationship: comments tend to get more aggressive or hostile over the course of time, in instances like this; and this is because of the fact that previously mentioned critique - often valid - was ignored. or you tried to bullshit your way out of it.

if people know that the effort doesn't mean much, they're not going to put that much effort in - and if your attitude remains as haughty as it has been, then it is only natural for the majority of the comments to begin to reflect that.

but you really want crits, so they give you crits. they're just not going to put the effort into the crits until you put in the effort to comprehend, dissect and attempt to apply them in some manner.

let me say that again: If you don't put in the effort, we're not going to put in the effort.

edit: btw you never told me how i was racist, you said i was in my rep but i messaged you and you ignored it, what the heck.

Downrepping Metaru just because he was a Chilean? A dick move, even if now you try to backpedal and play the "I did it 4 teh lulz" card.
I'm not especially fond of Metaru, but pretentious guys like you, who love to rate other people and bitch at them because they don't live according to what perfect, holy, mature and superawesome people like you order them to? I'm way, way less fond of these self proclaimed Internet Gurus, aka people like you. Happy now?

Quote:Downrepping Metaru just because he was a Chilean? A dick move, even if now you try to backpedal and play the "I did it 4 teh lulz" card.

he downrepped me with "back down to 39" because i was talking about having a 40 rep. it obviously isn't a serious thing, so i responded with something equally facetious!! sorry you can't see that. although i detest your idiotic terminology it really is "for the lulz".

you really, genuinely do not understand this place all that well much less its inhabitants.

and nice job actually talking about the main point of you dodging criticism.

I don't think you realize what an "ironic downrep" is and you're seriously getting mad over it and using it as an excuse for why you shouldn't listen to criticism?


Seriously dude. That's not an excuse. This is exactly the same shit we scolded Iceman for-- the difference is that he's actually shown improvement (even if it's in the tiniest amounts), whereas you keep on fighting this and giving reasons why you shouldn't listen?????

Everybody in this topic take a chill pill. I'll unlock this tomorrow.