Children Tikal and Chaos

[Whip the Rabbit]

I think it's the same thing actually, with all due respect.
Being a child is something that never happened in the game, but could (And most likely already) happen.
Same with Snake in a kart. It never happened, but could happen.
Plus, Tikal is a real character , as is Snake, thier just under different conditions, which still counts as official in a sense...

Just so nobody get's ticked at me, I'm not trying to get my sheet accepted, I'm trying to figure out why snake in Mario Kart was accepted.

[Teeks]

Look, Snake is an existing character. Putting him in Mario Kart style is no different than spriting Falco in Mario & Luigi style. Though he never appeared in that game or that style, that doesn't change the fact that he is an established character and can be accepted. It's not like they made up a new form of Snake for the SMK sheet. It's just Solid Snake in a kart. I see no reason why it shouldn't be accepted.

Your character, however, only exists to you. It has never appeared in a Sonic game or any other official Sonic continuity. There for it is a fan character and cannot be accepted.

Not accepting the Solid Snake SMK style would be stupid and if that's the case, no character sprited in a style they never appeared it should be accepted. And that is unfair and absolutely ridiculous.

[Whip the Rabbit]

Snake is a real character, which is why they could accept it.
Child Tikal is not.

Look, Snake is an existing character. Putting him in Mario Kart style is no different than spriting Falco in Mario & Luigi style. Though he never appeared in that game or that style, that doesn't change the fact that he is an established character and can be accepted. It's not like they made up a new form of Snake for the SMK sheet. It's just Solid Snake in a kart. I see no reason why it shouldn't be accepted.

Your character, however, only exists to you. It has never appeared in a Sonic game or any other official Sonic continuity. There for it is a fan character and cannot be accepted.

Not accepting the Solid Snake SMK style would be stupid and if that's the case, no character sprited in a style they never appeared it should be accepted. And that is unfair and absolutely ridiculous.

...I'm just not gonna go there. I can point alot of things that you contridicted yourself with, but I see it's pointless. People who are obssessed with being right are bound to what they say, I'm no exception.

[Teeks]

Go on then, point out my contridictions.


Child Tikal never appeared in any game. Ever. Snake, while he hasn't appeared in Mario Kart, has been in multiple games. There's a difference.

[Random Talking Bush]

Let's get this topic back on track, shall we? This topic isn't in Sprite Submissions, so we shouldn't be talking about whether it would be on tSR or not.

The sprites are alright, even though I can tell it's an edit off of Cream the Rabbit, and I guess the Chaos Chao's fine, too. You can't really get too detailed with Chao sprites, though. (I'm most likely wrong about that though. I'm kinda sleepy right now.)

(We still should re-write the rules a bit, though.)

[Whip the Rabbit]

I didn't want to have my sprite posted up. You guys's word is final. But the reason why doesn't make much sense to me.
and I thought Cshad moved this to sprite disscussion.

[Random Talking Bush]

and I thought Cshad moved this to sprite disscussion.

No, I did.

[Whip the Rabbit]

Oh. Whoops. my bad.

---

Go on then, point out my contridictions.


Child Tikal never appeared in any game. Ever. Snake, while he hasn't appeared in Mario Kart, has been in multiple games. There's a difference.

Your Treating Child Tikal as a different character. Tikal and Child Tikal are the same characters, just differently sprited. Which is were you contridicted yourself. You say Snake is sprited differently, and is allowed. if that's the case, then spriting Tikal to be a child is nothing more than making her a different style. I understand seeing her as a different character, I could probably make the same mistake as well...

[Darkshot]

No, it's a seperate character, which is why picking Mario in a sports game is different than picking Baby Mario, they are two seperate entities, even if they are technically the same person.

[Whip the Rabbit]

I guess....
my head's starting to hurt... I don't understand any of this anymore....

[Rakia]

Child Tikal is not Tikal.
Baby Mario is not Mario.
They are TWO DIFFERENT characters.
Get it, yet?

[Miles07]

Sprite discussion =/= Sprite submission. Now we are just talking about how the sprite sheet looks as a single project, not as a submission.

@ Whip:
Personally, I'd go mainly with what RTB said. The Chaos Chao might need to be a little less detailed, but also your Tikal needs to be a bit more... um, unique. You need more custom poses, something that shows that YOU have something to add to this. A little bit of YOU needs to be in this sheet. A new attack, for instance, or a custom-made (not edited) pose of her, like, praying, or whatever.
Something that makes others want to download YOUR sheet, if only for one animation. They would still need to give you credit for that pose. Get it?

[Whip the Rabbit]

Yeah, I get it. I'll try harder. Maybe I"ll make a sheet on an Official character next time.