Bat boy's stash of sprites

[Void-the-Bat]

Welcome to my stash of sprites hidden in my PC! Like the title said, these are sprite edits of, well, sprites! As of right now I only have this sprite:

I have also updated the Sonic 1 (2013) Sonic sheet because it was incomplete.

[Quirby64]

Wait, so this sprite is ~3 years old? Considering you said "THAT sprite with you guys AGAIN".
But anyways
I guess the sprite could have more "balance", because on the sign some of Sonic's spikes are hanging off whereas on Tails' side nothing's hanging off. Maybe that type of thing was in the Genesis original, but then I didn't notice.

[SmithyGCN]

It's... not a bad edit, but the bottoms of the faces have banding. Also, what Quirby said.

[Void-the-Bat]

Sorry for the bump, just trying to revive this.

Wait, so this sprite is ~3 years old? Considering you said "THAT sprite with you guys AGAIN".
But anyways
I guess the sprite could have more "balance", because on the sign some of Sonic's spikes are hanging off whereas on Tails' side nothing's hanging off. Maybe that type of thing was in the Genesis original, but then I didn't notice.

I agree on the balance part. The character's mugshot is actually coming out and in front of the sign post, which pretty much most, if not, all Classic Sonic games do this. I do see what you mean by the balance part.

It's... not a bad edit, but the bottoms of the faces have banding. Also, what Quirby said.

Yeah, this is 3 years old, after all.

[Gors]

no reason showing us something that is fucking 4 years old

make new things instead of one single old-ass thing

[Kosheh]

...yeah. Four years have passed. This itself was posted two years ago. Considering you're showing off sprites in this topic, there seems to be only...one.

Bumping a topic like this already is frowned upon - but I'll let it slide since

a) you're the author
b) the forum is moving kinda slow

However what I can't let slide is the lazy approach you're taking here to valid criticism. "This was made 4 years ago" isn't really a good reason because that feedback was posted shortly after you posted it, so you had like...what, 22 months between then and now to work on it?

Tell you what - if you're trying to revive this, as evident by your post: read the criticism posted and improve on this one sprite, or - if you're not interested in working on it, show off something new.
I can also close the topic if you'd like, should you change your mind...?