I hate to do a topic like this

[Ridge Troopa]

Jr. needs a wider head and more saturated colors. He's also a bit too small.
Honestly I'm not too fond of that Bowser lineart, but we'll see.

Sorry to say it bluntly but I hate the edits of Mario that you guys have been doing. They just don't look enough like Mario. Small eyes look really awkward because he just doesn't have small eyes like that. They're elongated. The head needs to stay the size it was originally, no smaller. Otherwise it's all out of proportion.

With that said, I fixed Mario's chin. I doubt there will be any complaints now.
Along with that I fixed Olimar a little (I really love the helmet you did, Koopaul, used that.) Made the Pikmin too.

[Ton]

I agree about the eyes. What do you think would make Bowser better, Ridge?

[Zern0]

A little edit on GameBoy's Ice Climbers

[Ninspriterx]

Dude, the thing is, Mario's nose looks too low like that. That's why his facial parts were moved up a pixel resulting in his eyes looking smaller but I made sure it looked fine in the end. The added chin to the lower facial features is.. a bit weird.

I say let's go with what the majority says.

edit: wait i think i made it work

[Ton]

I'd rather we go with the one who looks more like Mario...

[Wes]

Well some people have been saying that Bowser would look better facing sideways. The body still worked well with the side view, so I only changed the head. In the SSB games, Bowser stands 3/4 with his head facing forward, so it looks alright. Maybe I could changed the white rim of the shell, but that will depend on the arms once I add them. I shaded some of it, so maybe it'll look better now. I kept the other head though, because it will be useful for rotations in other animations.



I don't know if this will have an official pallete/color limit or not. I used Mario's red, skin, and white colors, but made my own yellow and green. Bowser's horns and shell spikes are the same color as his belly and snout (skin color/off-white), but his claws, teeth, eyes, and shell rim are all white. In Brawl, he has a more realistic design and his claws, teetch, eyes, and shell rim are all the same color as his horns and shell spikes. So if I need to reduce the color count, I can get rid of the whites and use the skin color instead.

Also, that latest Mario (nin's with the Sonic doodle next to it) definately is the best. Bigger eyes look like Mario, but the sprite itself looks better with smaller eyes and a higher nose.

[Ton]

Hm, I could live with the newest Mario and Luigi. And Wes, something looks off about Bowser's nose. The rest is looking great though.

[Kitsu]

I'm agreeing with Ton on almost everything he said recently. Though, I do think Nin's latest Mario looks perfectly fine.

@Ridge, the Pikmins' eyes look weird. You also need to do something to make the eyes on the yellow one stand out better.

[Ton]

Also, Wes, you might want to try bringing Bowser's eye into the "dip" of his muzzle.
The real question is this: Should we give Luigi his striped socks?

[Angelglory]

I think the tip of Bowser's nose needs to stick out one more pixel, it looks a bit squished in atm.

[Baegal]

I love the new style, much easier.

I really want to be a part of this, which character's are open?

[Kitsu]

The real question is this: Should we give Luigi his striped socks?

YES

@Baegal, most of them are. Pretty much anyone who hasn't had a new sprite posted is likely available.

[Wes]

Is this better?

[JoshR691]

added more shading and tried out a bunch of different colors for Squirtle...



...I'm still pretty shitty with colors (Or at least Blues)...And I'm not sure, but I think I may have gone a little overboard shading...

[Zern0]

5B is my favorite.