Player Pitch Pit (Discussion Complete)

[Alpha Six]

Didn't you say that already...?

[GaryCXJk]

Nope, that one referred to Bomberman not being called a Konami character.

[Kairos]

Y'know


Solink had an awesome idea in the thread for the third party characters. It had a lot of thanks.


So let's just say everyone agrees with it.

or something.

But really going back to the old "Two from one company" is dumb seeing as we had a goddamn poll.

[Sol]

Saying Geno isn't a Square-Enix / third party character is as much as a Travisty as wanting Travis over Samurai Goroh.

So, subsequently, we already filled Square-Enix' spot.

Okay, you're using the travisty thing way too much, it's lame now.

But yeah, I don't really think it's right to go "oh well Geno was in a Mario game so he's first party" That's like saying that retarded king character from the Zelda CD-i games is a first party character (stupid example but it's valid and the only one I could think of) because he was in a Zelda game. Whether or not Geno starred in a Mario game, he's Square-Enix's character, making him third party.

That being said, I don't think it's fair to have Geno take up Square-Enix's character spot. Personally, I'm not really sure why he's in the roster to begin with. Is he really such a big star, in relation to Nintendo, or video games in general?

[Solink]

That being said, I don't think it's fair to have Geno take up Square-Enix's character spot. Personally, I'm not really sure why he's in the roster to begin with. Is he really such a big star, in relation to Nintendo, or video games in general?

Geno and King Dedede were both first place in the Brawl poll.
He beat Megaman and Sonic. I think he should be an exception.

[Koopaul]

Geno can't be an exception. If you intend to have a FF rep you'd have two Square characters which wouldn't be fair.

Maybe six is good enough? SEGA, Konami, Capcom, Square, Namco and Treasure?

[Angelglory]

Maybe six is good enough? SEGA, Konami, Capcom, Square, Namco and Treasure?

This. Why struggle to pick eight when five or six do just fine?

[Kairos]

We were actually fine until people stated bitching about Travis.

[Teddy The Elite]

OMG! This whole conversation is getting so bothersome! It should be six/seven third parties AT THE MOST. All this is accomplishing is bull sh*t. These conversations are the ones that cause other fangames to end. I'm sorry for sounding like a moron, but this is ridiculous. When we can get past the flipping roster, we can actually start working on the damn game.

[Ton]

Geno for Square, Vivian to represent the Mario RPG series.

[Koopaul]

Ton did Villager (Animal Crosser) make it? What about Ray? Not that I care but I almost got the first-party roster made and organized.

I grew kinda tired waiting so I'm kinda doing it myself.

[Ton]

An AC character is definitely a great idea. It just needs a better name than "Animal Crosser" or "Villager." I've been tossing around a "final" roster for the last day or so (but we all know how that can change) so hopefully I'll be able to show you all my ideas tomorrow.

[Koopaul]

Well I didn't know that... I made this thinking that you weren't gonna put him in.

[HyperSonic92]

Well I didn't know that... I made this thinking that you weren't gonna put him in.

I thought the Dixie idea was ditched. Also when did we decided that Issac and the guy below him were gonna be playable?

[Wes]

I thought the Dixie idea was ditched. Also when did we decided that Issac and the guy below him were gonna be playable?

I don't know about Dixie or Ray, but Issac was decided a few weeks ago.

http://www.spriters-resource.com/communi...p?tid=9776
(check the date of the first post)

Pretty much everybody, including Ton, agrees that he should be in.